Who is Red John?

Theories of Smokey McPot (8)

I'm disappointed that it looks like Red John is actually on the list of 7 and will be revealed only 8 episodes into the season . . . then the show is gonna jump 2 years into the future ?? There has gotta be more to this than it seems I just hope it's killer and that this season doesn't tailspin like Heroes or LOST and ruin the series as a whole

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

who said Red John correctly guessed the list of 7 ?    Jane is just going along with Red John cause he knows who he is ...  just like most episodes we the audience are guessing based on the facts presented and at the end Jane reveals who the killer is with some sort of deduction      Jane is just using Red John's list of 7 to get closer      and btw one of Lisbon's team is workin for Red John ... most likley Van Pelt  she was the only one added to the team after Jane

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In regards to the Red John voice theory. . . Every time you hear Red John's voice it's realy Simon Baker's voice (just whispered and strained). Listen carefully

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #7278 • By Smokey McPot
Show this theory

RedJohn isn't someone on the list of 7 and it isn't someone who is dead or an obscure character who has only appeared once It's Patrick Jane.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Watch the last scene of the pilot episode  Patrick Jane laying under the Red John smiley face while the Red John theme music is playing  F@%#in Creepy  Has anyone else noticed everytime you hear Red John's voice it's really Patrick Jane's (just whispered and a little strained)   it can't be anyone on the show except Patrick Jane because we already suspect everyone on the show except the most obvious. . . Patrick Jane!!!  He's the only one even close to having Red John's skills      it's why Red John hasn't killed him   it's why Patrick can't catch Red John   there is more proof that Red John and Patrick Jane are the same person than anyone else      this whole list of 7 is another Timothy Carter    Reede, Bertram, and McAllister(and everyone else on the show in law enforcement) are part of this secret tyger tyger cop cult doing Red John's dirty work and survailance  Red John is heavily involved with Visulize and Bret Stiles  who is using thier power and influence through cop cult to aide and cover up Red John's crimes    why and how was Patrick Jane allowed onto the CBI in the first place?    Through Visulize he is using the cop cult to keep an eye on him when he is Patrick Jane       it will b a letdown if it is a random or obscure character  there will be no significance                                    

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #3707 • By Smokey McPot
Show this theory

i can't believe some people actually believe Bruno Heller when he says stuff like Red John isn't Jane   or  Red John Is one of the seven suspects.   The whole series has been nothing but misderection. Even if jane finds out who red john is in the season 6 finale and captures or kills him we'll find out in season 7 it was not red john.  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If it's someone from the list it's Partridge gotta be  i suspected him after rewatching the pilot episode but dissmised it when he didn't appear again in the first season   when he popped up in the season 2 finale (a red john ep written by bruno heller) my radar went off and in season 5 he showed up in two episodes(on a red john season finale ep written by bruno heller) an all my suspicions were confirmed by just the fact that Partridge is on jane's list   and he's the only one the show hasn't hinted  is red john       everone else is either too obvious or not obvious at allI've got every season on dvd and have watched every episode at least 3 times each the more i think about it the more i'm convinced Red John is more than one person(a cult within Visulize?) and is heavily involved with Visulize (mentored by or working for Bret Stiles) 1-Stiles' knowledge of Red John    2-Red John's accomplices appear cult like  3-Visulize has members in the CBI  4-The smiley face on the barn at the Visulize farm       
Red John has a connection to Jane's carni past  1-there's a reason Red John hasn't killed jane  2-maybe knows or is Jane's Dad or brother in law Danny 3- could be related to someone the Jane's ripped off 4- the knowledge of Jane's happy memory 5- Shaun Barllow seems to know a lot about red john and describes jane's dad as wicked  
 
 it's not one one of the guys on the list   every possible Red John reveal has been a fake out this is just another cock tease another ploy by jane so red john will let his guard down    It's gonna be dissapointing if it is just one of the seven people on the list     it's gonna b more than one person or someone not on the list #1-Janes dad #2-Mashburn #3-Minnelli #4-Christine Frye #5-That blind chick is not blind  lol

But still . . .revealing Red John has been Jane all along would make this the greatest show ever going back and rewatching every ep knowing jane is really red john would b crazy



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on